Monday, August 10, 2009

Today's Globe: "Life insurance industry pushes pension fix"


Below are some insightful comments posted by readers of today’s Globe article about how Canada’s cartel of life insurance companies, who successfully lobbied to kill the competition known as income trusts, are now busy lobbying against proposals by some provinces to set up a new national system

Comments:

SO what happens if say..manulife goes bankrupt?

The insurance companies want to keep us on the hook.

The image of "fox in the henhouse" comes to mind when these [life insurance] companies start suggesting "solutions".

Always suspicious when the insurance cartel says it really, really wants to help out the little people. Sure!

The only reason the insurance companies don't want a national defined contribution pension plan is because it will eat into their profits. That's it.

Yes, do lets give the pension system to a "for profit" private enterprise, ideally a foreign owned one, what with the success Alberta has had with energy deregulation, privatization is the way to go to Edhellmonton in a hand basket.

I find it interesting that the same people that virtually bankrupted many a retirement plan, and retiree, now proclaim that they have the answer, that they are the ones to trust. Have we not seen this story before, how many billions in bail-out has their arrogance cost us thru this recession? I will not be one to trust these people again, they have been exposed as the fraudsters that they are, without true knowledge of the financial system. "Give me a small amount of money, and I will give you back millions down the road" they say, Are they all from Nigeria? Sure sounds like the same scam to me. Sorry, there is no 'free lunch'. Work hard, spend wisely, live within your means, be good to each other, but to hand my hard earned money over to these bumbling fools?...I say no!

Private for-profit insurance companies that were once mutual companies now want absolute control of pensions.
If these firms were still mutual companies whose primary interest was the policyholder, I might believe they cared about people and pensions.
But they aren't mutual companies anymore. They're private outfits whose primary aim is huge earnings at any cost -- for their executives, sales staff, and shareholders.
Letting these people take larger control of Canadian pensions would be criminal -- something a lot of people will fight to prevent.

Industry need to fix their own house before telling other to. Their role is to sell normal annuities that give us the benefits from people in our cohort dying - just like pension plans.
Yet when I tried to buy one, the price they wanted was more than the price of a Gov't RealReturn Bond drawn down to the age of 95.
In other words, they were not even prepared to "break-bulk" much less give me any benefit from my cohort dying.

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Our condolences


Our sincere and heartfelt condolences go out to the family and friends of Jack Lawrence and the partners and staff of his firm, Lawrence Asset Management Inc.

Lawrence Asset Management Inc are Founding Members of CAITI.

Jack Lawrence is someone who believed in the integrity of the Canadian Capital Markets and someone I had the privilege of worklng with at Burns Fry Limited. Jack Lawrence’s high regard for ensuring the integrity of the markets is, no doubt, what led him to join CAITI as a Founding Member.

Our work in exposing the truth about the patent falsehood known as tax leakage on behalf of investors like Jack Lawrence, those who entrusted him to manage their money and the millions of other Canadians who were aggrieved by this reckless policy. will continue. Our ultimate victory in exposing this falsehood will be diminished only by Jack’s absence.

Bay St. heavweight dies in Muskoka crash

Jack Lawrence, Carol Richardson killed on impact when float plane crashes on takeoff\
Aug 04, 2009 01:15 PM
DANIEL DALE
STAFF REPORTER
Toronto Star

The man killed in a Muskoka plane crash yesterday afternoon was Bay St. luminary Jack Lawrence, founder and chief executive officer of the Toronto investments firm Lawrence and Co.

Carol Richardson, a woman the company identified as Lawrence's companion, also died in the crash.

Lawrence, 75, was a prominent Bay St. figure for decades, originally making his name as a bond trader and rising to the position of president at the firm Fry Mills Spence.

As chairman of the successor firm Burns Fry, he oversaw its 1994 sale to the Bank of Montreal for $403 million.

Lawrence, 5-foot-3, was renowned for his dual passions for fitness and fiscal policy.

Born in Orangeville, he played hockey, basketball and football at the University of Western Ontario. At Lawrence and Co., he organized and completed an office triathlon when he was in his mid-60s.

According to a statement released by the firm, he spent his final weekend playing tennis and canoeing with friends and family.

An advocate of low taxes and the reduction of government spending, Lawrence toured Canada in the 1990s advocating fiscal conservatism and warning of Canada's "looming debt crisis."

He felt vindicated when Finance Minister Paul Martin adopted some of his preferred positions in attempting to reduce the federal deficit.

Lawrence had four children with his first wife, from whom he separated in 1975, and two children with his second wife, Janice, whom he married in 1978.

In 2000, he told the Star that he regretted some of the hard work that allowed him to climb the corporate ladder so rapidly.

"I didn't spend as much time with the family as I should have," he said.

"I regret that. Everything in life is a trade-off. There were a few difficult years."

Stockwell Day's commitment: Not worth the paper it's written on




November 8, 2005.

Dear Mr. Laxton

Thank you for expressing your concerns about the confusion the Minister of Finance has caused on income trusts.

Income trusts have helped numerous Canadian companies grow and flourish and enabled ordinary Canadians to generate more income for their retirement years. The federal Liberal government's reckless decision last September to cancel advance tax rulings on income trusts caused Canadian businesses to lose billions of dollars in market capitalization and Canadians to lose thousands of dollars of personal savings.

Canadians investing in good faith to save for their retirement deserve certainty, not a government review of how the Liberals can grab more taxes from them.

We know that Canadians draw regularly form their investments to supplement their retirement savings. When the value of their investments drops as a result of government indecisiveness, so does their retirement income. It is time the government stopped penalizing our citizens.

My colleagues and I in the Conservative Party are committed to maintaining income trusts as a valuable savings and investment tool for Canadians.

Thank you again for contacting me,

Yours sincerely,

[signed Stockwell Day]

Stockwell Day, M.P.
‘Okanagan-Coquihalla
Official Opposition Foreign Affairs Critic

Thursday, July 30, 2009

The phony lamenting of Tony Clement




Today we learn that Tony Clement is having second thoughts about the billions that were pumped into the automakers and made with no concomitant requirement to disclose the salaries paid to their executives. Pumping billions becomes his justification for disclosure. Meanwhile a few days ago Tony Clement was professing concern over the foreign takeover of Nortel.

Is this sudden need on the part of Tony Clement for disclosure and his nationalistic feelings phony or are they real?

Tony Clement or phony lament?

What about the $35 billion that was lost by income trust investors, caused by a tax that was premised on the argument that income trusts cause tax leakage.....that was accompanied by ZERO disclosure by the Harper CONservatives on that allegation? Shouldn’t losing $35 billion at least entitle Canadians to the facts on which that policy was based? How is knowing what the CEO of GM makes compare in importance to proof about the central allegation of a government policy that saw investors lose $35 of their life savings and a policy whose outcome may have been to cause the very problem that it alleged to have fixed? Is a government induced loss of that magnitude not demanding of disclosure, Tony Clement, or is your need for disclosure selective in nature, and strictly politically motivated?

What about the $100 billion wave of takeovers of Canadian companies by foreigners that Harper’s income trust tax induced.....or is the Harper government only concerned about protecting bankrupt companies like Nortel form foreign takeover, meanwhile formally approving the sale of Canada’s largest telco (BCE) into the hands of controlling foreigners who would have loaded it up with $38 billion in junk bond debt in order to pay zero taxes and $793 million less a year in taxes that had BCE been permitted to maximize shareholder value by way of an income trust? How does the sale of bankrupt Nortel to Ericsson merit this Industry Minister’s concern, whereas the sale of Prime West Energy to Abu Dhabi Energy only merited a letter from the prior Industry Minister to the head of Abu Dhabi Energy from Jim Prentice, in which Abu Dhabi was invited to take over as many Canadian energy companies as it liked?

Foreigners have free reign over Canada’s prosperous and cash rich companies, but not our bankrupt companies? Only governments can demand disclosure, but not their citizens? These are the phony lamentings of Tony Clement and the Harpercrite CONservatives.

Meanwhile, where do the Liberals stand on these issues. It can not be blithely assumed that they are better......as if only by default? Specifically, what is their policy to restore this theft of Canadians life savings, perpetrated on the completely false and fraudulent notion of tax leakage?


Clement calls for salary disclosure

Minister says executives at automakers bailed out with public money would be `wise to revisit' issue

Jul 30, 2009 04:30 AM
Les Whittington
Ottawa Bureau
Tony Van Alphen
Business Reporter

OTTAWA–Auto company executives shouldn't be hiding their salaries from taxpayers who kept their companies afloat with billions of dollars of public money, Industry Minister Tony Clement says.

"From a public relations point of view, it would be probably wise for them to revisit that issue," he told reporters yesterday.

Clement's comments came after the Star reported that General Motors of Canada Ltd. and Chrysler Canada would not publicly disclose the compensation packages of their top Canadian executives despite heavy public aid.

While Clement said public perception is paramount when it involves taxpayers' money, he added that current executive salaries at GM and Chrysler in Canada are within limits of loan agreements with Ottawa and Queen's Park.

As a condition of providing support to the struggling companies, governments set limits on executive pay, including performance bonuses. But the governments did not disclose the limits or the actual pay.

"There is a sunshine law on their salaries but none of the Canadian salaries are high enough to be part of the sunshine law that we enacted in both Canada and the U.S.," Clement noted. "They are certainly within the law (to keep salaries secret)."

As part of its restructuring, GM of Canada said it cut executive salaries by 10 per cent; reduced pay for salaried staff and trimmed benefits and pension plans earlier this year.

The company said yesterday the governments conducted due diligence, including a comprehensive review of compensation for all employees, before advancing loans.

"GM Canada will be certifying that the company continues to comply with the agreement including provisions related to compensation," the company said.

In the U.S. where executives of bailed-out financial companies have walked off with salaries and bonuses far beyond the dreams of average workers, compensation has become an explosive issue.

Parent GM, which received billions from the U.S. government, has revealed the pay of its top managers including chief executive officer Fritz Henderson, who will receive $1.26 million (U.S.) this year.

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation said Canadians have a right to know full details of what the auto companies are doing with government money in the largest corporate bailout in the country's history.

"Taxpayers expect the firms to jealously guard their money, to spend it carefully, to invest it wisely and to report on it more fully," said federation director Kevin Gaudet." Only with full transparency will this be guaranteed."

The federal and Ontario governments provided U.S.-based parents GM Corp. and Chrysler Group LLC with more than $14 billion (Canadian) this spring to help keep the companies, including their Canadian operations, alive. The governments own almost 12 per cent of GM and 2 per cent of Chrysler.

Ontario NDP Leader Andrea Horwath, who introduced a private member's bill earlier to cap executive pay for firms receiving government aid, said Premier Dalton McGuinty should force public disclosure.

"Given that Ontario taxpayers are now key shareholders in these companies and essentially footing the bill on their executive salaries, his blissful ignorance is no longer an option," Horwath added. "He must demand complete transparency on this matter."

In rejecting the bill, McGuinty said the government wanted to strengthen the economy and create jobs rather than " interfere with salaries awarded to executives."

Saturday, July 25, 2009

Ottawa can do much to 'beef up' pensions


Edmonton Journal
July 24, 2009

Re: "Ottawa, provinces look to beef up pensions," The Journal, July 22.

I find it ironic that the federal government and the provinces are meeting in Calgary to consider how to encourage Canadians to save more since the economic downturn eroded savings.

The truth is that the Tory government in Ottawa, aided and abetted by the provinces, especially Ontario and Alberta, devastated seniors' incomes with the legislation introduced in November 2006 announcing the taxation of income trusts.

Seniors lost billions in their portfolios and to this day the federal government has not been able to justify its actions or provide evidence of taxation losses because of the existence of income trusts.

In fact, time has shown that the feds have lost billions of dollars in taxation as a direct result of this legislation, which was politically motivated at the request of big insurance companies and other financial institutions.

Yes, the second shoe to fall was the economic downturn, but the first shoe to fall was the devastation brought on with the taxation of income trusts and the impact this decision has had on seniors' incomes and the deterioration of income trust values since 2006.

S. J. Rideout, Edmonton
© Copyright (c) The Edmonton Journal

Ottawa can do much to 'beef up' pensions


Edmonton Journal
July 24, 2009

Re: "Ottawa, provinces look to beef up pensions," The Journal, July 22.

I find it ironic that the federal government and the provinces are meeting in Calgary to consider how to encourage Canadians to save more since the economic downturn eroded savings.

The truth is that the Tory government in Ottawa, aided and abetted by the provinces, especially Ontario and Alberta, devastated seniors' incomes with the legislation introduced in November 2006 announcing the taxation of income trusts.

Seniors lost billions in their portfolios and to this day the federal government has not been able to justify its actions or provide evidence of taxation losses because of the existence of income trusts.

In fact, time has shown that the feds have lost billions of dollars in taxation as a direct result of this legislation, which was politically motivated at the request of big insurance companies and other financial institutions.

Yes, the second shoe to fall was the economic downturn, but the first shoe to fall was the devastation brought on with the taxation of income trusts and the impact this decision has had on seniors'incomes and the deterioration of income trust values since 2006.

S. J. Rideout, Edmonton
© Copyright (c) The Edmonton Journal

Yes, but then Mark Carney is a world authority on wealth destruction


Yesterday in the Globe it was reported that: “"Yet Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney stopped short of celebration, saying it will take more than a year to replace the wealth destroyed by the financial crisis. "

Mark Carney is a world authority on wealth destruction, having personally been responsible for evaporating $35 billion of Canadians’ retirement savings and the source of billions in annual taxes to Ottawa, as a sole result of his scheme to kill income trusts based on his fabricated tax leakage argument.

Unlike the losses sustained by investors as a result of the “financial crisis”, the losses sustained by investors under Mark’s Own Financial Crisis are permanent losses...never to be recovered......since 31.5% of the income has been hived off by the government as the means to kill income trusts in order to ensure the dominion of the corporate model at the behest of corporate CEOs in Canada.....and a perpetuation of all the corporate abuses that brought about the world’s financial crisis.

PS: Where’s Mark’s proof of tax leakage? How is Canada better off as a result of, for example Abu Dhabi owning Prime West Energy or OMERs owning Teranet or the leverage buyouts of Canadian trusts by US Private Equity players, none of whom pay any taxes, rather that having these companied owned by average Canadians who were paying taxes at an average annual rate of 38%?

Did Mark Carney pass Grade 3 math? Is he capable of basic addition and subtraction, or will 2 plus 2 equals 3, remain the unchallenged falsehood of Mark Carney’s wealth destruction formula? One thing is for sure, Mark Carney’s intellectual dishonesty has been the means for his rapid career advancement......even if it meant destroying $35 billion of Canadians’ retirement savings and destroying the only means by which many Canadians had a hope for a dignified retirement. I guess, some people are more ambitious than others?

Meanwhile, just exactly where are our Paid Elected Members of Parliament who are supposed to defend us from blatantly obvious schemes like the one hatched by the overly ambitious Mark Carney at the behest of many of his former clients at Goldman Sachs? Is losing $35 billion of Canadians’ retirement savings not on their radar screen? Just who do they think they are elected to serve? The CEO’s of Canada or the taxpayers of Canada?